UPTroutBum on Jan 12, 2009January 12th, 2009, 9:18 am EST
Pretty broad statement there. On my local streams in northern michigan, I have caught most brookies on nymphs, especially the bigger ones, I have caught some small guys on drys like an adams, never any bigger than 8, maybe its just my luck.
" The true fisherman approaches the first day of fishing season with
all the sense of wonder and awe of a child approaching Christmas." John Voelker
NW PA - Pennsylvania's Glacial Pothole Wonderland
RleeP on Jan 12, 2009January 12th, 2009, 9:43 am EST
It is sort of a broad statement, but it isn't (IMO) without some modicum of truth, even if it is a more comparative truth.
Here's what I mean by this:
In my experience, of the 3 species of trout/char most of us fish over in the East/Midwest, I have found that day in and day out, brook trout are the least likely to be free-rising. This is among wild populations and presumes we are not talking about fish that live (as brookies often do..) in a setting sufficiently infertile that they cannot afford to let virtually any feeding opportunity pass.
I don't think the difference in this between the species is that pronounced, but I do think it is real.