This genus contains the legendary Hendricksons and Sulphurs of the East and the equally important Pale Morning Duns of western waters.
No scientific name in American angling literature is more renowned and at the same time capable of more confusion than the genus name "Ephemerella
." It is important that anglers have a good overall grasp of its taxonomic history if they are to make any sense out of the rich literary heritage involving this mayfly name.
By the time American angling literature began to take serious note of entomology in the decades of the early to mid 20th century, Ephemerella
was considered a "super-genus" in the family Baetidae
, containing all of the important species to anglers in the subfamily Ephemerellinae. Taxonomists organized them by association with "type" species that were referred to as "groups" within this very large and unruly genus.
This organizational structure held sway until the 70's when they were recognized as separate from the Baetidae
with their own family, the Ephemerellidae
. The "groups" (after a little name changing and reorganization) were given subgenus status, but in conformance with taxonomical convention,the nomenclature retained the use of the name Ephemerella when referring to individual species
genus status. More change occurred towards the end of the century as consensus formed around the subgenera achieving full generic status. The broad use of Ephemerella
was then dropped in favor of the new generic names.
These changes were necessary in that they addressed many problems exposed in older taxonomies. Unfortunately, all during this period the changes were reported with varying degrees of accuracy and acceptance. For anglers this was exacerbated by the continued use and reliance on older entomology texts in many circles. Be that as it may, recent or updated angler entomologies now recognize that many of the old Ephemerella
species are spread out among several genera in the Ephemerellidae
family. These include the various Blue-Winged Olives and Western Green Drakes of the Drunella
genus as well as several important species scattered in genera like Attenella
, to name a few.
Despite these revisions in classification, the Ephemerella
genus still contains arguably the most important species in North America, and remains a "super-genus" to anglers.
There is a lot of variation; refer to the genus species hatch pages for details.
Jpsully on May 23, 2008May 23rd, 2008, 1:22 am EDT
There are some beautiful photos posted on that forum under the "Fishing" section, and titled "Bugs are cool". My guesses as to ID are: first 2 pics (same fly)- Stenacron (orange tint, two tails, mottled wing and banded femur), third pic - Ephemerella Attenella (3 tails, slate wings and faded olive body), last 2 pics (same fly) would appear to be Maccafertium (Grey Fox - not March Brown) based on 2 tails and light coloration. Am I correct in my assumptions? Any help you could provide would be appreciated. Thanks.
"Bear Swamp," PA
GONZO on May 23, 2008May 23rd, 2008, 2:17 am EDT
Just in case you'd like another (unsolicited) opinion while you're waiting for Jason's response, I'd say you've got it about right. Here's what I see:
1st mayfly (female dun)--probably Stenacron interpunctatum. It's a bit hard to see the telltale Stenacron wing marking in the photo, but it sure looks like it.
2nd mayfly (female dun)--could be Attenella attenuata (or Drunella lata). You may see the former in older texts as Ephemerella attenuata and the latter as either Ephemerella cornuta or Drunella cornuta. (Both of these could be hatching now. Size might help. If it's ~ 10mm, it's probably lata--later season hatches of lata are smaller. If it's ~ 8mm, it's probably attenuata.)
3rd mayfly (male dun)--Maccaffertium vicarium. This used to be split into March Brown (Stenonema vicarium in older texts) and Grey Fox (Stenonema fuscum in older texts), but both are now under M. vicarium.
I hope that helps.
Jpsully on May 23, 2008May 23rd, 2008, 3:29 am EDT
Thanks, that is definitely helpful. You are right on with your details.
Just what I was looking for.
"Bear Swamp," PA
GONZO on May 23, 2008May 23rd, 2008, 3:31 am EDT
Softhackle on May 24, 2008May 24th, 2008, 1:45 am EDT
Nothing to do with your flies, JP, but where in blazes have you been?
"I have the highest respect for the skilled wet-fly fisherman, as he has mastered an art of very great difficulty." Edward R. Hewitt
Flymphs, Soft-hackles and Spiders: http://www.troutnut.com/libstudio/FS&S/index.html