I had a Coolpix 5000 and, as all Nikons I have used did, took beautiful pictures. Now I have a little Fujifilm Finepix XP, and it also takes wonderful photos, and also waterproof (I think I actually have dropped it in the water). Almost all of the photos I have posted on here in the last four years have been taken with this camera, the others by friends' cell phone cameras.
The trick with these little cameras is to shoot as many shots as you can, and one or two of them will come out fantastic, but of course I was also taught this 30 years ago in Photography for Field Biologists (Ectachrome E6 days - life is SOOOO much easier now!). My instructor, now passed away but never forgotten, always advised, find your subject, get it in focus, and then BRACKET like hell! Pretty much a universal photography truth...and in those days, there were soooooo many ways to goof it up if your were developing your own slides. However, our instructor also would say that he would give you a cigar if and only if you made a mistake he had never made himself. Whenever someone screwed up, he would inevitably say, "No cigar for that one."
Don, if you find your ideal camera and get some good shots, feel free to post them on here, we all love to see each others' pics.
Jonathon
P.S. Jason, our noble leader of Troutnuts, gets some pretty spectacular photos and I'm sure his gear has to be pretty rugged to survive his adventures (see the front page of this website for details).
No matter how big the one you just caught is, there's always a bigger one out there somewhere...