Keying this one out using Zloty & Pritchard 1997:
-No
ganglionic markings on
sternites 2–8
-
Posterior margins of sternits 6–8 without numerous spines
-
Mesal gill extension well developed (I really don't like the "well developed" language when it's subjective, but in this case the other option doesn't lead anywhere productive)
-Tails pale in
basal 1/3
-Larger species (13–16 mm) — this one is just shy of 12 mm, but closer to 13 than to <10
-Spring emergence
This all points to
Ameletus vernalis.